“The Church is the one thing that saves a man from the
degrading servitude of being a child of his time.”

— G.K. Chesterton

A reader recently reminded me of a post I first published in September, 2013, and requested that I run it again. 

As one commenter succinctly noted, “In what cosmos would Christ carry a gun?”

You might also want to check out this recent op-ed called “Why Christians Must Support Gun Control.” 

A sacrament is that which brings into being what it signifies. A handshake signifies friendship and it brings into being more friendship. An embrace signifies warmth, and it brings into being more warmth. The Sacrament of Reconciliation signifies forgiveness and it brings into being more forgiveness. The Eucharist signifies sacrificial love and it brings into being more sacrifice, more love.

A gun is an anti-sacrament. It signifies hatred and fear and shooting one, or practicing shooting one, brings into being more hatred, more fear, and always, always, more guns.

I’m not talking about those who hunt food to eat: our neighbors who would of course be the first to call for responsible gun control. But beyond that, clearly, the time has long since passed, if it ever existed, when private citizens could amass enough weapons to rise up against the tyranny of the government.  Clearly, the principal and overriding purpose of gun ownership is to arm ourselves against each other.

Which wouldn’t be necessary in the first place if our lack of sane thinking and laws hadn’t led to so many people owning so truly insane many guns. (See the recent NYT article “What Explains U.S. Mass Shootings? International Comparisons Suggest An Answer”).

To own a gun is to live your whole life on high alert for a moment that, unless you’re a gang member, run a meth lab, work in organized crime, or have enlisted in the military, the overwhelming odds are will never come. It’s to stand eternally in front of the mirror like Travis Bickle in Taxi Driver and sneer at an imaginary foe, “Are you talking to me?”

To walk through the world quietly, peacefully, unarmed, is to live your whole life in freedom. Sure, someone may come along and randomly shoot you but a building might fall on you, a drunk driver might plow into your car, or you might be struck by lightning, too.

Sure, the violence our culture worships will continue to erupt in ever more berserk violence, most of it committed with guns. Meanwhile, though, you get to enjoy each moment to its fullest, secure in the knowledge that you will never, ever, either accidentally or intentionally, shoot someone else.

If we want to live in a world where guns are not needed, we get to act as if we live in that world already.

That’s how we bring into being the Kingdom of God.

That’s how we begin to answer the call of Pope Francis: “No more war. War no more.”



  1. Heather, thank you for this post- again, so well put. The words "A gun is an anti sacrament" is a sermon in a sentence. I have been mulling over it since I read it.

    Along these lines, I was taken by a little graphic that popped up on Facebook the other day concerning Japan's zero-tolerance policy re gun violence and how it severely limits gun ownership. It fits well with your post:

    (I prefer watching it with the sound off and captions on.)

    Love the photos. It looks like you are getting a another photographic voice with your new camera! (Colors are perhaps a bit brighter? Can't put my finger on it but there is a difference from those taken with your old camera.)

    Blessings for a fruitful Advent. XXOO Mary Beth

    1. Mary Beth, wonderful youtube! Watch it, folks, very short. Called "Why Japan Has No Mass Shootings." Japan often has less than 10 gun-related deaths a year. The "right to bear arms" in the U.S. costs 33,000 lives a year. Guns are anti-life.

      In this season of light, let's be for life. To walk through the world unarmed in no more "unrealistic" today than it was in Christ's day.

      God bless you, MB! Glad you like the new camera. Merry Christmas and much love–

  2. Anonymous says: Reply

    Being Catholic requires, among other things, sound reason.This consideration of firearms not only falls well short of reason, it makes little attempt at reason, which is worse.

    1. Right–in fact, the insistence on a "right to bear arms" causes so many deaths; so clearly makes our lives more dangerous; not more safe, and is so clearly based on fear rather than love that it goes AGAINST all reason…and against every teaching of Christ….

Leave a Reply

Discover more from HEATHER KING

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading